Pessimism vs. Optimism: What's the Alternative?


Hope does not traffic in denial or depend on progress. It faces truth and depends on God, Sayles writes.
Nothing is easier to come by than pessimism. There are plenty of reasons for it.

The economic outlook is (still) gloomy: scarce jobs, skyrocketing healthcare costs and crashing retirement investments. Political discourse is relentlessly coarsening. Leaders can't seem to put the common good ahead of narrow self-interest.

There are our personal anxieties: a family member struggles against cancer and endures treatments that seem as threatening as the disease. A colleague at work buried a loved one whose death came sooner than seems right to anyone. Friends worry and weep over close relationships that are fraying, even ripping and tearing. Others live with an unending loneliness.

Pessimism is plentiful and cheap, and it makes for a lousy life. Researchers in the area of "emotional intelligence" have demonstrated that while people with a "pessimistic explanatory style" have a firmer grasp on the facts and the givens of life, they also lack the will to take action in the face of those realities.

Optimists, while not as realistic as pessimists, tend to be more engaged in the search for solutions to the problems they confront than are pessimists. (Not being confused by the facts appears to have some adaptive value!)

This research confirms what most of us know intuitively: Pessimism drains away the energy we need to do something about the problems we face.

Optimism serves us better. Optimistic, positive people are more fun to be around, are more likely to be our leaders, and, most often, enjoy greater success than pessimistic people.

The trouble with optimism, though, is that it depends on the idea – the illusion – of progress: the belief that things are improving and people are getting better.

And optimism thrives on denial of the hard truths we know about the persistence of evil, the randomness of tragedy, and our own flaws, weaknesses and failures.

We need hope instead of optimism. Hope does not traffic in denial or depend on progress. It faces truth and depends on God.

Hope does not hinge on things moving onward and upward; it turns on the dying and rising of Jesus from the grave.

To have hope, we need a story, a narrative that gathers up yesterday, today, tomorrow and the time beyond time. We need the story of Jesus, which unfolds against the backdrop of the history of God's faithfulness to Israel.

In the life and death of Jesus, God has undergone everything that drives us to despair. God has come to our sides and entered into our experience. God has embraced all our diminishments and limitations.

God has shouldered our burdens and frustrations. God has been touched, even wounded, by our failures, sins, guilt and shame.

But God does not come into our desperate conditions merely to identify with us: God means to redeem and renew us, by raising us up just as surely as God raised Jesus from the dead.

Resurrection means that we live, not under judgment, condemnation and death, but in mercy, grace and life. Not in anxiety, despair and fear; but in faith, hope and love.

Hope is not resurrection in isolation from the cross; it is resurrection made necessary and possible by the cross.

Hope is not a wholeness unacquainted with brokenness; it is brokenness made whole by grace.

Hope always bears the marks of prior wounding, and walks into the future on legs once paralyzed by fear.

Authentic hope is always paradoxical: embodied by the risen, but eternally scarred, Jesus.

The Apostle Paul expressed the paradoxical nature of hope in this way:

"Therefore, since we are justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom we have obtained access to this grace in which we stand; and we boast in our hope of sharing the glory of God. And not only that, but we also boast in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, and endurance produces character, and character produces hope, and hope does not disappoint us, because God's love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit that has been given to us" (Romans 5:1-5).

Guy Sayles is pastor of First Baptist Church of Asheville, N.C. This column first appeared on his blog, From the Intersection.

Related Articles

 

Share:          
Tags: Guy Sayles, Hope, Optimism, Pessimism


Powered by Bondware
News Publishing Software

The browser you are using is outdated!

You may not be getting all you can out of your browsing experience
and may be open to security risks!

Consider upgrading to the latest version of your browser or choose on below: